Michael Caine is not a man to be messed with…. He’s faced a swarm of killer bees, Jack the Ripper, Steven Segal, The Joker, and even Hollywood’s most famous rubber shark, Joan Rivers. Those were all practice however, for here in Harry Brown; Caine is up against the yoof of today, in all their happy slapping glory. Well at least a heightened version of the gang culture of today. I’m not saying this stuff doesn’t happen, I’m just saying in Harry Brown, these are the most contemptuous, vile, irredeemable people you could ever meet. The chavs of Harry Brown make Caine’s previous scuffs with Jack the Ripper and Jaws seem about as threatening as indigestion.
Make no mistake, this is one of the bleakest and most depressing films of recent years, and I left the cinema feeling cold and emotionally drained. Many sequences, such as an already infamous sequence in a drug den, is like something from a David Lynch directed nightmare, making this alongside Eden Lake seem to usher in a whole new genre of Hoody Horror. It’s one of the few times that as the credits rolled, I hoped for a proceeding two minute short film about kittens, just to put me into a sense of false security.
So while I walked home feeling uneasy with the film, the one thing I was sure about was Michael Caine, delivering a wholly believable character study. He makes Brown sympathetic, despite the acts he finds himself committing. However, this in part is due to the film’s depiction of the gang members as pure evil, making his actions dangerously commendable. The surrounding performances are also solid, but I wasn’t entirely sure about Emily Mortimer. This may have not been entirely her fault, as her character, as well as Officer Hickock felt underwritten and often stereotypical. It’s defiantly a well made film, looking and sounding fantastic. The cinematography is suitably bleak and the music is low key, tense and eerie.
Therefore as you can tell, Harry Brown certainly isn’t a bad film; in fact at times it’s very good, especially for a debut feature. But while for many the film will be a responsibly unglamorous parable of a generation falling to pieces, the films heavy handedness and debatable ethics are troublesome. While the film aims for Gran Torino, it quickly falls into the right-wing sadism of the Death Wish series, lacking the subtlety of Eastwood’s film. The questions Harry Brown raises are important; making the film worth viewing. Audiences will have to make their own opinions on the films questionable ethics and its handling of such important issues. It can very briefly be summed up by a quote from an anonymous user of a popular online forum: “It’s a bit like falling to sleep with Get Carter on in the background…Having just read the Daily Express”.